Pick the workout you enjoy, not the “best” one

Enjoyment helped people persist in exercise studies. Choose a version you want to repeat, and keep the evidence in perspective.

By Hirvesh Munogee · · 3 min read

Pick the workout you enjoy, not the “best” one

You want to exercise, so you look for the most useful routine. Then you find yourself avoiding it. Before choosing another demanding plan, consider a different question: which version would you enjoy doing?

You can care about the long-term goal and still choose an activity that feels good while you do it. Enjoyment is worth including in the decision.

Pick the workout you enjoy, not the “best” one.
Habit Science #10: Pick the workout you enjoy, not the “best” one.

What the studies found

In a study with 61 gym-goers, participants were asked to choose either the exercise they enjoyed most or the one they considered most useful. Those choosing for enjoyment did 53% more repetitions than those choosing for usefulness.

That result concerns persistence in an exercise task. It does not establish that every enjoyable workout produces better long-term fitness results. The useful lesson is narrower: how the activity feels can matter to how much you do.

In research on New Year’s resolutions, enjoyment predicted who was still sticking with the activity two months later. Its perceived importance did not. Yet about seven in ten people said they would use the long-term payoff to motivate themselves.

These findings suggest a practical adjustment. Keep the reason you want to exercise, but give the experience of exercising a place in your plan. Try the four rules from the video.

1. Pick the version you enjoy

If you would rather dance than use a treadmill, try the dance class. If a walk appeals more than the gym, begin with the walk. Write down what you would actually like to do rather than choosing solely by what sounds impressive.

You can make the choice specific. “Go to the dance class I like” gives you something to book. “Do the best workout” still leaves you deciding what to do when the time comes.

2. Add a treat to the activity

Try music you like or a podcast you want to hear while you walk. For another habit, you could bring a favourite snack to your study session. Choose something that fits comfortably alongside what you are doing.

Put the enjoyable part into the plan itself. Queue the playlist or choose the episode before you start. Treat these as examples to test, rather than expecting the gym study’s percentage to carry over to your own routine.

3. Let the goal start you

Your reason for exercising still has a place. You might want to get into better shape. Write that reason down, then write how you want the next session to feel: a class you like, music you enjoy, or a walk you look forward to.

Use the goal to choose your direction. Use the enjoyable version to plan today’s action. You do not have to repeat the distant payoff to yourself throughout a session you dislike.

4. Look for another version

If your chosen activity has no appeal, try changing the activity. You could replace a workout you dread with a different kind of movement, or try a different class. Keep the goal in view while giving yourself permission to choose another route.

Ask yourself afterwards whether you want to do that version again. You can use your answer when planning the next session. The aim is to find an action you are willing to keep choosing, rather than to prove you can endure a particular routine.

Choose your next session

Pick an activity you enjoy and put it in your calendar. Prepare the part you look forward to as carefully as the exercise itself. The studies offer a reason to take enjoyment seriously. Your next session is a chance to try that idea in your own day.

Sources

Make it a habit with Habit Pixel

Color a pixel for every check-in and watch your consistency grow. Free on iPhone, iPad and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Scan to downloadOpens the App Store or Google Play

4.9 from 150+ reviews

Habit Pixel 4.9 · FreeGet