One slip ruins nothing. Quitting after it does

After one slip, it is tempting to give up for the day. Research on dieting and procrastination suggests a kinder response helps you get back on track.

By Hirvesh Munogee · · 4 min read

One slip ruins nothing. Quitting after it does

You skip the walk, eat the biscuit, or put off the task you promised yourself you would start. Then a second thought arrives: the day is ruined anyway, so why bother? That thought often does more damage than the slip itself.

This episode looks at why one lapse can turn into a lost day, and why treating yourself kindly afterwards seems to help more than telling yourself off. Try the four rules the next time a plan goes wrong.

One slip ruins nothing. Quitting after it does.
Habit Science #17: One slip ruins nothing. Quitting after it does.

What happens after a slip

In a classic 1975 study, Herman and Mack gave people no milkshake, one, or two before an ice cream “taste test”. People who were not dieting ate less ice cream after a milkshake, as you might expect. Dieters did the opposite and ate more. Researchers later called this the “what-the-hell” effect: the diet is already broken, so you might as well carry on.

Kindness seems to interrupt that spiral. In a study by Adams and Leary, college women ate a doughnut, and some were then encouraged to think about it with self-compassion. Among the strictest dieters, that brief nudge reduced distress and led to less candy eaten afterwards.

The pattern shows up beyond food. Breines and Chen gave 86 students a difficult test. Those who then read that they should try not to be too hard on themselves spent about 5.1 minutes studying for the retest, compared with 3.4 minutes for students who saw no message. A message designed to boost self-esteem did not clearly do better than nothing. And in a study of procrastination before two exams, students who forgave themselves for delaying on the first one procrastinated less before the second.

Keep these results in proportion. They are small studies, the procrastination one relied on self-reports and could not show cause and effect, and the self-compassion message did not improve test scores directly. Still, they point the same way: a harsh reaction to a lapse does not seem to make the next attempt more likely.

1. One slip isn’t a fall

Treat a lapse as a single event, not a verdict on the day or on you. You missed one walk. The rest of the day is still open, and so is the habit.

If you have read about the “never miss twice” idea, this is its first half. The research there suggests one missed day does not undo your progress. The risk lies in what you tell yourself next.

2. Talk to yourself like a friend

Notice the words you use after a slip. If a friend skipped their run, you would probably not call them lazy or hopeless. You might say that everyone has off days and suggest trying again tomorrow.

Give yourself the same sentence. Something like “Everyone slips sometimes. Try not to be too hard on yourself” is close to the wording used in the studies. Kindness here is not an excuse to stop caring. In the test study, it went with more effort, not less.

3. Do the tiny version today

The “what-the-hell” moment says the day is a write-off. Answer it with the smallest version of your habit. Meditate for one minute, do two press-ups, or read a single page.

The aim is to keep the habit going while the slip is still fresh. A tiny version tells you the plan is still running, and it is much easier to start when you feel tired or frustrated.

4. Plan the comeback, not the punishment

Skip the extra-long workout or the strict new rule meant to make up for the lapse. Punishment plans tend to feel heavy, which makes the next attempt harder to begin.

Instead, decide when and where you will do the habit next. “Tomorrow, 7am, same spot” is enough. Write it down, put out what you need, and let the next attempt be an ordinary one.

Your next slip

Slips will happen with any habit you keep for long enough. Decide now what you will say to yourself and what the tiny version will be, so the plan is ready before you need it.

Related reading: “Never Miss Twice” Rule: Resilience Beats Perfection.

Sources

Make it a habit with Habit Pixel

Color a pixel for every check-in and watch your consistency grow. Free on iPhone, iPad and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Scan to downloadOpens the App Store or Google Play

4.9 from 150+ reviews

Habit Pixel 4.9 · FreeGet